← The Herb LibraryWinter’s living materia medica

Cohosh, Blue

Caulophyllum thalictroides

Cohosh, Blue
Wikimedia Commons · H. Zell · Image source · cc-by-sa-3.0

Overview

Blue cohosh is a woodland plant of eastern North America with smoky blue-green leaves and dark blue, berry-like seeds. Its root has a long history in Native American and early American midwifery, where it was called 'women's best friend'. Today it is better known for its risks than its gifts, and it is unrelated to black cohosh. It is included here mainly for its history and as a caution. How it compares: Black cohosh and blue cohosh share a name and a woodland habitat, but they are unrelated plants: black cohosh (Actaea racemosa) belongs to the buttercup family (Ranunculaceae), while blue cohosh (Caulophyllum thalictroides) belongs to the barberry family (Berberidaceae). They are NOT interchangeable. Black cohosh is a relatively gentle, well-studied herb used mainly for menopausal hot flashes, menstrual cramps and muscular aches; its effects come from triterpene glycosides and phenolic acids, and it does not appear to act like estrogen in the body. Blue cohosh is a strong uterine stimulant whose alkaloids (including N-methylcytisine, which acts like nicotine) and saponins can constrict blood vessels, strain the heart and harm a developing baby; it has been linked to serious heart and stroke injuries in newborns. Historically the two were sometimes combined by midwives to bring on labour, which is now considered dangerous. For menopause or cramps, black cohosh is the better (and far safer) choice; blue cohosh has no safe home-use role. Both are also at-risk wild plants, so cultivated sources are best.

Plant family

Berberidaceae

Parts used

Root and rhizome (underground stem). Seeds are poisonous.

Actions

Emmenagogue · Oxytocic · Uterine Tonic · Antispasmodic · Anti-rheumatic · Diuretic

Affinities

Uterus

Body systems

Reproductive · Musculoskeletal

Taste profile

Acrid (a sharp, irritating sensation in the mouth) and bitter.

Energetics

Warming.

Traditional use

Native American peoples and early midwives traditionally used blue cohosh in the last weeks of pregnancy and at birth to bring on and strengthen labour and to help expel the placenta, and for delayed or painful periods and other gynaecological complaints. It was classed as a strong, 'pushy' emmenagogue (an herb that brings on menstruation), unlike gentler uterine herbs. It was also used for rheumatic aches and gout. In my coursework, it was noted as now contraindicated before birth and as something only trained midwives historically worked with.

Current use

Blue cohosh is still sold as a tincture, but modern safety reviews conclude that its risks outweigh any benefit, and no quality clinical trials support its use. It is also listed as an at-risk plant because of over-harvesting from the wild. I don't recommend it for home use.

Preparation

Historically, the dried root and rhizome were taken as a decoction (simmered root tea) or a tincture. The bright blue seeds are poisonous and are not used; they have poisoned children who ate them.

Dosage guidance

Please don't take it internally at home. If used at all, it should only be under the direct supervision of a qualified practitioner.

Cautions & contraindications

Blue cohosh is potentially toxic. Please never use it during pregnancy or breastfeeding. It contains N-methylcytisine, an alkaloid that acts on the same receptors as nicotine; this can raise blood pressure and heart rate and cause sweating, nausea, vomiting and muscle weakness, so please avoid it with heart disease, high blood pressure or diabetes. Its saponins (caulosaponin and caulophyllosaponin) constrict blood vessels, including the coronary arteries that feed the heart, and stimulate the uterus, which is thought to explain reports of heart attack, heart failure, stroke and oxygen-starvation injuries in newborns whose mothers took it near labour. Another alkaloid, anagyrine, causes birth defects in grazing animals, and N-methylcytisine caused malformations in rat embryos, so it is considered teratogenic (able to harm a developing baby). The raw seeds are poisonous, and the powdered root irritates the mucous membranes (the moist linings of the nose, mouth and gut).

Evidence notes

Winter's HERB303 page is a course resource template only (name, Latin name, family). Web-sourced seed pending Winter's review. Sources: Plants For A Future (https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Caulophyllum+thalictroides); Drugs.com Natural Products (https://www.drugs.com/npp/blue-cohosh.html); NIH LactMed (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK501780/)